Phoebe Health Logo

Phoebe’s Rural Health Report Charts ‘A pattern of Delays and Denials’ in Medicare Advantage

A person reviewing a Rural Health Report on the problems with Medicare Advantage.Albany, GA | November 17, 2026 – Medicare Advantage plans accounted for the vast majority of Medicare claim denials Phoebe Putney Health System received in fiscal year 2025, leaving $15.2 million in claims unpaid for six months or longer and patients in limbo. Those are among the findings publicized in a new Rural Health Report, released today, that examines the impact of the public-private insurance program for seniors.

The second edition of Phoebe’s Rural Health Report finds that these patterns of delays, excessive administrative requests and claim denials threaten seniors’ access to critical healthcare services in underserved areas like southwest Georgia. They also add considerable financial pressure to rural hospitals like Phoebe that survive on narrow margins.

Medicare Advantage is an alternative version of the government-funded healthcare program for seniors, managed through private insurance companies. MA plans have proven popular, with enrollment surpassing half of all Medicare beneficiaries in recent years. The Congressional Budget Office projects that MA’s share of Medicare enrollees will reach 63% by 2034.

But MA plans have some key differences from original Medicare, including narrower networks of participating providers and a tendency to require prior authorization for coverage of certain services or procedures.

A Phoebe analysis of 12 months’ worth of MA claims data uncovered troubling trends, including:

  • MA plans accounted for 83% of Medicare claims denials, compared to 17% for traditional Medicare
  • An average 73.2 days to claims payment, well above federal guidelines
  • A 45.1% increase in downcoding admissions claims from the top six plans to trigger a lower reimbursement

“Our one-year deep dive into Medicare Advantage claims activity surprised even us in what it demonstrated: A clear pattern of obfuscation, delay tactics, excessive requests for records and unjustifiably high rates of denials for the patients we serve,” said Tom Lynch, Vice President of Managed Care at Phoebe. “Rural hospitals like ours are asking Congress to step in and enact strong protections against this kind of predatory behavior.”

Find the new Rural Health Report edition here.